All-Americans
Gavin Smith was an All-American honoree in 2024 and 2025
 Josh Dennison
2024
Long snapper
Romeoville, Ill.
2024 - AP, first team
|
 Reid Pakkebier
2024
Linebacker
Cedar Rapids, Iowa
2024 - AP, second team
|
 Gavin Smith
2024, 2025
Cornerback
Audubon, Iowa
2024 - AP, second team
2025 - AP, first team; AFCA, second team
|
 Blaine Hawkins
2021
Quarterback
Ankeny, Iowa
2021 - AFCA, first team; AP, first team; D3football.com, first team
|
 Tanner Schminke
2021
Wide receiver
Boone, Iowa
2021 - D3football.com, first team; AP, first team
|
 Joshua Mayhew
2021
Offensive guard
Aurora, Illinois
2021 - D3football.com, second team
|
 Hunter Maddy
2021
Defensive lineman
Mystic, Iowa
2021 - D3football.com, fourth team
|
 Blade Durbala
2020-21
Defensive lineman
Blairstown, Iowa
2020-21 – D3football.com, first team
2021 - D3football.com, fourth team
|
 Jon Alberts
2019
Kicker
Huntley, Ill.
2019 – AFCA, first team
D3football.com, first team
|
 Sam Markham
2016
Wide receiver
Atlantic, Iowa
2016 – D3football.com, third team
|
 Jacob Edleman
2014
Defensive back
Mechanicsville, Iowa
2014 – AFCA, Associated Press, second team
|
 Danny Samson
2013
Defensive end
Baxter, Iowa
2013 – D3Football.com, first team
|
 Shane Wong
2010
Defensive end
Pleasant Hill, Iowa
2010 – D3Football.com, third team
|
 Guy Dierikx
2007
Defensive back
Port Byron, Illinois
2007 – D3Football.com, third team
|
 Greg Altmaier
2007
Linebacker
Iowa City, Iowa
2007 - D3Football.com, third team
|
 Brant VerMeer
2006
Punter
Montezuma, Iowa
2006 – Football Gazette, third team
|
 Taylor Vanden Wynboom
2006
Defensive end
Britt, Iowa
2006 – Football Gazette, second team
|
Nick Reed
2006
Offensive guard
Springfield, Illinois
2006 - D3Football.com, third team
|
 Vance Schuring
2005
Running back
Pella, Iowa
2005 – D3Football.com, third team
|
 Ryan Johnson
2005
Offensive tackle
Britt, Iowa
2005 – D3Football.com, third team; Football Gazette, third team
|
 Mark Sanger
2004
Linebacker
Britt, Iowa
2004 – D3Football.com, third team; Football Gazette, third team
|
 Austin Bonnema
2002
Linebacker
Pella, Iowa
2002 – D3Football.com, third team
|
 Justin Snyder
2000
Defensive end
Panora, Iowa
2000 – D3Football.com, first team; Hewlett-Packard Division III SIDs, second team
|
 Reid Evans
2000
Center
Newton, Iowa
2000 – Hewlett-Packard Division III SIDs, third team
|
 Jeff Sanger
1999-2000
Linebacker
Britt, Iowa
1999 – Hewlett Packard Division III SIDs, third team; Football Gazette, third team
2000 – AFCA, D3football.com, third team; Hewlett Packard Division III SIDs, second team
|
Steve Perkins
1999
Defensive tackle
Oskaloosa, Iowa
1999 – Hewlett-Packard Division III SIDs, second team
|
 Andrew Paulsen
1998
Defensive back
Plainfield, Iowa
1998 – AFCA; Hewlett-Packard Division III SIDs, second team
|
 Matt Paulsen
1997
Defensive back
Plainfield, Iowa
1997 – Hewlett-Packard Division III SIDs, first team; Football Gazette, second team
|
 Matt Bandstra
1995
Center
Pella, Iowa
1995 – Hewlett-Packard Division III SIDs, second team
|
 Mark Kacmarynski
1994, 1996
Tailback
Mallard, Iowa
1994 – Division III SIDs, first team; Football Gazette, first team; Gagliardi Player of the Year Award finalist
1996 - AFCA; Hewlett-Packard Division III SIDs, first team; Football Gazette, second team; Gagliardi Player of the Year Award finalist
|
 Rick Sanger
1994-95
Linebacker
Britt, Iowa
1994 – Division III SIDs, first team; Football Gazette, first team
1995 – AFCA; Hewlett-Packard Division III SIDs, first team
|
 Jeff Helle
1993-94
Offensive tackle
Maquoketa, Iowa
1993 – Kodak AFCA; Champion Division III SIDs; Football Gazette, first team
1994 – Schooner’s AFCA; Associated Press, second team, Division III SIDs, first team; Football Gazette, first team
|
Bill Mulder
1992
Linebacker
Spirit Lake, Iowa
1992 – Kodak AFCA; Associated Press, second team; Champion Division III SIDs, first team; Football Gazette
|
 Tim Lewis
1991
Defensive end
Oskaloosa, Iowa
1991 – Champion Division III SIDs, third team
|
Kris Reis
1989
Linebacker
Coon Rapids, Iowa
1989 – Kodak AFCA, first team; Pizza Hut Division III SIDs; Football News
|
 Mike Stumberg
1988
Nose guard
Grundy Center, Iowa
1988 –Kodak AFCA; AP; Pizza Hut Division III SIDs, first team; Football Gazette, first team (Defensive POY); Domino's AFCA Player of the Year nominee
|
Ron Saak
1988, 1990
Linebacker
Grundy Center, Iowa
1988 – Pizza Hut Division III SIDs, third team; Football Gazette, second team
1990 – Champion Division III SIDs, second team; Football Gazette
|
Steve Flynn
1988
Quarterback
Iowa City, Iowa
1988 – Football Gazette, first team
|
Jeff Blythe
1986
Defensive end
Williamsburg, Iowa
1986 – Associated Press; Football News, first team
|
Rich Thomas
1984-85
Defensive line
Eddyville, Iowa
1984 – Football News
1985 – Kodak AFCA; Associated Press; Football News
|
Scott Froehle
1984
Defensive back
Iowa City, Iowa
1984 – Kodak AFCA
|
Don Taylor
1977
Tailback
Toronto, Canada
1977 – Kodak AFCA
|
Al Dorenkamp
1974
Linebacker
Meservey, Iowa
1974 – Kodak AFCA
|
Vern Den Herder
1969-70
Defensive end
Sioux Center, Iowa
1969 – Kodak AFCA; Associated Press; NAIA
1970 – Kodak AFCA; Associated Press; NAIA
|
 Doug Van Boven
1967
Tailback
Hudsonville, Michigan
1967 – Associated Press
|
Dennis Descoteau
1966
Tailback
West Liberty, Iowa
1966 –NAIA
|
