Each school's finish in each sport is determined and given a numerical worth by inverting the finish (i.e. since 2012-13, first place is worth eight points, second place is worth seven points, third place is worth six points, etc). In case of ties, the worth of all places involved are totaled and divided by the number of teams in that tie. Each school's finish in all sports is then totaled, and the school with the largest number of points shall be awarded the Elmer Hertel Men's Sports Championship Trophy for the following year in the men's league and the Marjorie Giles Women's Sports Championship Trophy in the women's league. The school displaying overall excellence in men's and women's sports is awarded the Conference's All-Sports Championship Trophy.

 

		All-Sports		Elmer Hertel - Men's			Marjorie Giles - Women's
2024-25		2nd - 14 points		4th	50.2 points		2nd	57.5 points
2023-24		2nd - 16 points		3rd	50.5 points		1st	57.5 points
2022-23		3rd - 15.5 points		4th	50.0 points		t-2nd	49.0 points
2021-22		t-4th - 11 points		5th	46.5 points		4th	41.2 points
2020-21
2019-20				3rd	30.0 points		5th	26.5 points
2018-19		t-3rd - 13 points		3rd	49.5 points		4th	43.0 points
2017-18		4th - 13 points		4th	50.2 points		3rd	43.7 points
2016-17		2nd - 15 points		2nd	55.5 points		3rd	44.8 points
2015-16		t-4th - 12 points		5th	43.0 points		5th	34.8 points
2014-15		2nd - 14 points		2nd	53.85 points		2nd	44.0 points
2013-14		t-3rd - 11 points		2nd	50.5 points		5th	36.7 points
2012-13		3rd - 12 points		2nd	46.3 points		4th	35.5 points
2011-12		4th - 11 points		3rd	57.2 points		6th	43.2 points
2010-11		t-3rd - 12 points		4th	51.5 points		4th	46.3 points
2009-10		3rd - 13 points		2nd	60 points		5th	39.7 points
2008-09		4th - 12 points		4th	49.2 points		4th	48.9 points
2007-08		t-4th - 11 points		4th	52.2 points		5th	44.4 points
2006-07		t-2nd - 13 points		2nd	58 points		5th	39.8 points
2005-06		t-2nd - 14 points		2nd	57.2 points		4th	46.2 points
2004-05		t-3rd -12 points		3rd	48.5 points		5th	45.1 points
2003-04		t-2nd - 14 points		5th	45.1 points		1st	51.0 points
2002-03		t-4th - 13 points		4th	56.7 points		5th	49.7 points
2001-02				4th	57.0 points		t-2nd	59.0 points
2000-01				3rd	69.0 points		1st	69.0 points
1999-2000				3rd	69.0 points		3rd	66.5 points
1998-99				4th	65.0 points		5th	57.5 points
1997-98				5th	68.0 points		3rd	65.0 points
1996-97				3rd	48.5 points		4th	45.0 points
1995-96				2nd	48.5 points		t-3rd	41.5 points
1994-95				1st	61.5 points		3rd	46.0 points
1993-94				1st	56.5 points		t-1st	49.5 points
1992-93				1st	57 points		3rd	48.0 points
1991-92				1st	59 points		4th	42.5 points
1990-91				1st	59 points		3rd	47.5 points
1989-90				1st	56 points		1st	50.5 points
1988-89				4th	46.5 points		3rd	48.5 points
1987-88				1st	55.0 points		3rd	48.5 points
1986-87				1st	56 points		1st	56.0 points
1985-86				1st	50.5 points		1st	50.5 points
1984-85				1st	58 points		1st	48.5 points
1983-84				2nd	52.0 points		1st	46.0 points
1982-83				2nd	52.5 points		1st	50.5 points
1981-82				1st	51.5 points
1980-81				1st	47.5 points
1979-80				1st	55.5 points
1978-79				1st	55.5 points
1977-78				2nd	53.5 points
1976-77				1st	52 points
1975-76				5th	38.5 points
1974-75				2nd	44.5 points
1973-74				3rd	44 points
1972-73				2nd	45 points
1971-72				3rd	32.5 points
1970-71				3rd	42.5 points